MS Photo 3

Homes for Sale on Casey Key

Casey Key is a barrier island that features distinctively large luxury homes. Nearly every home is either on Sarasota Bay or the Gulf of Mexico. Some homes on the bay side even  have their own beach house on the gulf  side directly across the street. Older homes typically are purchased for the land and are torn down to make way for an extraordinary new home. The south end of Casey Key has the only public beach facilities, along with some dining and shopping. The access to Casey Key on the north end is by a swinging bridge that allows only for one car to cross at a time.

 Video Tour of Casey Key Real Estate     

Perhaps the most unique and unspoiled Florida “Key,” Casey Key is a barrier island situated on the West Coast of Florida. Consisting almost entirely of single-family homes, Casey Key, Florida real estate is highly sought after by those looking for life in the most pristine Florida environment. This key is known as “Old Florida” at its best.


Casey Key is covered in a delightful canopy of tropical trees, with winding Gulf-front streets that make for remarkable Sunday drives among Sarasota’s most sought after homes.

There are no chain hotels, high-rise buildings or traffic jams on Casey Key, much to the delight of local residents and visitors. The island is only about eight miles long, and stretches from Siesta Key on the north to the Island of Venice at the southern tip. Two bridges, one of which is an old “swing bridge,” provide access to Casey Key. Most of the island is less than 300 yards wide, with several beaches along the Gulf on the west side and Little Sarasota Bay to the east.

Casey Key, Florida real estate is also highly valuable thanks to the higher ground elevations of the island. A total of more than 400 residences on the key are occupied by a combination of full-time, seasonal, and vacationing families. The properties generally range from around $1.5 million to over $5 million, with a current average sale just above $3 million. Casey Key, Florida real estate sales in recent years include of one of the highest-priced single-family homes to sell in the entire Sarasota County — the property sold for $9 million.

The different types of properties available on Casey Key include direct Gulf-front properties, Bay front properties, and Gulf-to-Bay estates. For Gulf-front properties, land values range from $20,000 to over $30,000 per frontage foot. Bay front land is the most expensive, selling for around $1.5 to $2 million for the average 100-foot wide lot. Gulf-to-Bay land sells for about $25,000 to $35,000 per frontage foot.

From enjoying beaches and boating to blissful sunsets, residents who are lucky enough to live in Casey Key are continually grateful for their pristine surroundings. Best yet, amenities such as major grocery stores, drug stores, and department stores are just minutes away by bridge.

For more valuable information on Casey Key, Florida real estate, please contact real estate experts Brian Meskil and Laura Benson of the Sarasota Homebuyers Guide today. Brian can be reached at 941.780.3468